We are total fans of the Duck stories; this one is very different from the others in our opinion. When I read it to myself I was very disappointed... but when I read it to my 4 year old son who thinks Duck is fantastic (especially Fix-It Duck - he knows that one word for word nearly now!) he laughed and laughed and did say that it was different to the other books but was just as funny and Duck was just being Duck! Gaynor